I don't always read books in pairs, but lately it seems that's how they've been coming into my hands. About a month ago one of my dearest, bookish friends was raving about a book called
Life after Life. She said, "The whole story is based on the idea --'What if you could keep reliving your life until you got it right?'" She followed by describing the first few chapters. I was drooling in anticipation.
At the library a few days later, I came across what I thought was
the book. I got home and started to devour the first pages. The book I found myself reading seemed
nothing like the one described by my friend..
.because it wasn't the book described by my friend. It was a different book, also newly published, called
Life after Life.
So I read them both.
The first
Life after Life, I thought of it as the doppelganger, is by Jill McCorkle. The tale begins with a woman's account of the death of an elderly person and much of the action takes place in a nursing home. Before you dismiss it, you should know that the story was surprisingly good. The novel had a strong Southern feel, which I always appreciate, and it asked some deep questions about life and death. I couldn't help but muse about my own mortality, regrets, and best memories. Though I enjoyed it, I probably won't remember it for very long.
Contrarily, the other
Life after Life by Kate Atkinson was extraordinary. Every time Ursula intuitively learned from a mistake in one of her previous lives, I cheered. The elegant prose captivated me. I was intrigued by the way that Atkinson introduced historical figures into the fabric of her fiction, suggesting alternative paths for the course of history. The book also invited the question, "How important are a single person's actions?"
I happily endorse either of the Life after Life novels, but if you only have time for one, I'd choose the one by Kate Atkinson. My friend's raptures rang true when I read the book myself. Amazon.com rated it one of the best books of 2013, but I wouldn't be shocked if it became one of the most celebrated pieces of literary fiction published in this new century.